James Oppenheimer closed a $21.5 million purchase of 253 South Shore units in Chicago's Jackson Park TOPA pilot, with no tenant association matching the deal, The Real Deal reported November 17, 2026. Berkadia placed a $16.6 million Fannie Mae loan.
The trade is an early large-format exit under Chicago's expanded right-of-first-refusal rules tension between local operators and out-of-state distress sellers.
What Changed Hands?
| Element | Detail |
|---|---|
| Buyer | New City Property Management (James Oppenheimer) |
| Seller | Astoria Properties entities (John Olar) |
| Units | 253 |
| Buildings | 8 |
| Location | East 70th St / South Crandon Ave, South Shore |
| Price | $21.5 million (~$85,000/unit) |
| Ask | $24 million (Kiser Group OM) |
| Debt | $16.6 million Fannie Mae (Berkadia) |
| Brokers | Kiser Group (Noah Birk, Aaron Sklar), both sides |
Brokers described meticulous local management and near-100% tenant retention, contrasting distressed out-of-state owners that plagued South Side recoveries.
How Did TOPA Apply?
Tenant Opportunity to Purchase Act rules in the Jackson Park pilot require:
- 60+ days notice before listing (for post-effective-date listings)
- Contract disclosure to tenants after seller accepts an offer
- 90 days for a tenant association with 75% of occupied units to match the deal
Here, the portfolio listed before April 6, 2026, so TOPA's listing clock did not restart. Seller attorney James Erwin said only contract notices were needed.
No association formed. Sale closed Thursday (week of November 17).
Aaron Sklar told The Real Deal TOPA added complexity and delays even on this path, but stakeholders were relieved to pass buildings from one hands-on operator to another.
Why Did Council Expand TOPA?
Chicago created the Jackson Park pilot by widening the 2020 Woodlawn test to slow gentrification around the Obama Presidential Center, covering South Shore, Woodlawn, and Greater Grand Crossing.
A Northwest Side pilot began March 2025, where tenants already sued landlords and brokers alleging skipped notices (Logan Square case, October injunction on a triplex).
Oppenheimer's deal shows listing date and operator reputation still drive whether TOPA bites.
How Does Oppenheimer's Track Record Matter?
Oppenheimer has stacked South Shore with long-hold promises:
- $14 million for 164 units at 7100 South Shore Drive (2022)
- $22 million for 250 units at Shorewind Towers (2023)
That narrative helped brokers market stability versus merchant exits in a TOPA market.
The Numbers Worth Writing Down
- 253 units / 8 buildings
- $21.5 million close (~$85,000/unit)
- $24 million marketed price
- $16.6 million Fannie Mae debt
- April 6, 2026 TOPA effective date (listing predated)
- 75% tenant association threshold to match (not met)
- 90 days statutory match window (not triggered on listing)
TOPA Adds Friction, Not Always Veto Power
Jackson Park proves Chicago multifamily liquidity still exists when sellers are local, tenants do not organize, and deals predate pilot effective dates.
For national allocators, South Shore is a regulatory beta: California housing bonds fund supply, while TOPA shapes who can sell to whom.
Sources
- Oppenheimer pays $22M for South Shore apartments in tenant-purchase zone, The Real Deal, November 17, 2026
- Progress Residential FTC Settlement, Your CAIO, November 2026
- Senate BAHA Permitting Bill, Your CAIO, November 2026